The Charmed Legacy Wiki
"I'm keeping his number in case I have trouble sleeping." - Phoebe tells Piper about the man

One of Phoebe Halliwell's fellow college students, Melatonin Boy, actual name unknown, participated in a lab with the Charmed One and the two decided to have lunch together.[1] however, Phoebe was displeased by how boring the man was, giving him the nickname Melatonin Boy reflecting how he could put someone to sleep because he was so boring.

When she returned home from the lunch date, she referred to the man by the nickname and asked her sister Piper what was wrong men. She then revealed that during the date, all she could think about was Billy Appleby, a character from her favorite film, "Kill It Before It Dies".


  1. Season 2, Chick Flick